Map Feedback : ns2_fracture

Zefram
3639
Posts
235
Location
United States of America
Joined
16 November 2012
28 January 2014 - 17:34 CET
#1
This thread is reserved for any feedback for:

ns2_fracture
http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=150058573

maintained by Howser
http://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561197961118209/

All thoughts are greatly appreciated.
www.twitch.tv/Zefram0911
Stranger
5804
Posts
18
Location
Canada
Joined
30 September 2013
30 January 2014 - 03:06 CET
#2
Just scrimmed on it, I played marine commander. There are too many overhangs for medpacks to hit. Probably around 50% of my medpacks hit a beam.
Tico
5888
BEAST INFECTION
Posts
100
Location
United States of America
Joined
24 November 2013
30 January 2014 - 10:48 CET
#3
StrangerJust scrimmed on it, I played marine commander. There are too many overhangs for medpacks to hit. Probably around 50% of my medpacks hit a beam.


this is just user error tbh i was rine comm as well and i was fine... but tbh if walls could be texture, the map would be awesome. it plays very well. :D
Howser
Noavatar
Modder
ns2_fracture
Posts
10
Location
Earth
Joined
19 September 2013
30 January 2014 - 18:48 CET
#4
Hey guys just to let you know the remake wont be released till Saturday morning! This is not ideal but real life slowed me down this month. It'll have a light art pass, and fix all the issues we've found through testing. I'll post a proper, informative update later tonight.
Thanks
ZEBROE
5641
Posts
73
Location
SAIGON, Nepal
Joined
12 August 2013
31 January 2014 - 15:54 CET
#5
StrangerJust scrimmed on it, I played marine commander. There are too many overhangs for medpacks to hit. Probably around 50% of my medpacks hit a beam.


This map has elevated levels in many rooms, which may seem to cause medpack struggles but from my experience, the levels don't seem to block a clear path of meds to your marine from top-down view. I think the med issue is fine on the map.

J
SkogsMulle
3031
Jolly Cooperation
Posts
11
Location
Faroe Islands
Joined
25 October 2012
3 February 2014 - 00:32 CET
#6
This stair is a real mess walking in, running in, anything with a marine is aweful, sometimes you get stuck, sometimes you just get stuck and then released and sometimes there is no problem at all, which ends up me jumping in the stairs because I don't want it to be different everytime I am trying to get up the stairs!
http://imgur.com/TUIrJZ3
Howser
Noavatar
Modder
ns2_fracture
Posts
10
Location
Earth
Joined
19 September 2013
3 February 2014 - 05:20 CET
#7
I've Updated after the last two long games.
The marine run times to the marine natural RTs and Neutral areas have been reduced by a few seconds on all routes. This will have some large implications for balance. But the map is too big and so I'll have to try balance more through cover, vents and chokes rather than the run distances.
Stairs fixed. And Capped a few holes

Thanks for playing the map. Please keep the feedback coming and I'll keep improving.
Mega
1942
pubstars
Posts
225
Location
Germany
Joined
28 September 2009
4 February 2014 - 20:24 CET
#8
you can watch our glorius match here if you like: http://www.twitch.tv/m/395574

the map is just amazing big and so maybe a bit alien favored

and the first time i was loading the map and checking out the vents i was like god dammit these vents are pitch black dark.... and the entraces are hard to spot

never saw an other map where the vent entraces are so hard to spot

but then i saw the vents on the left side have all this red emergency lightning in it and thought

all vents need this or at least a yellow thing around the entrance
Howser
Noavatar
Modder
ns2_fracture
Posts
10
Location
Earth
Joined
19 September 2013
7 February 2014 - 21:41 CET
#9
Thanks for all the feedback and I've got a lot of information from watching the games played. Here's the changes for this Sundays release:
*fix the vents for this Sunday and Im downsizing alien side run times a bit too.
*The view and cooling tanks are being merged into one room which can be a suitable staging ground for marines.
*Arrivals is also getting opened up a little so marines have a bit more room for a base there.
*Atlas is getting expanded a bit to be a bit more interesting both visually and in terms of gameplay.
*Flow central coloum is getting down sized and the corridor to the park is getting moved up to the north so there isn't a blind spot near the powernode.
*Screening simplified so there's not that awkward loop outside ceremony

The logic that lead the map to be as big as it is was to discourage marines rushing alien start. I've since changed my mind on this. I'll try balance more through cover and vents as opposed to extending run times.
Please keep the feedback coming! :D
SkogsMulle
3031
Jolly Cooperation
Posts
11
Location
Faroe Islands
Joined
25 October 2012
10 February 2014 - 00:18 CET
#10
I found another stair today that annoy me, it is at the node in Ceremony I think.. West side tech point!
It's just the same thing like the other stair I posted about!
http://imgur.com/7qgusGb

Also, you are amazingly fast at fixing stuff, love it! :D
Howser
Noavatar
Modder
ns2_fracture
Posts
10
Location
Earth
Joined
19 September 2013
10 February 2014 - 00:50 CET
#11
Ah nice post! I must of missed that one. I'll fix that and the stuck spot in upload for tomorrow.
I'm currently unsatisfied with how the view is so hard to contest for marines. I'll review that over the next few games and try come up with decent solution.
Also preparation is bit of a nothing room atm I'll redesign that once a good idea comes to mind.
I managed to get a lot of information for watching wonga Vs frequencey so thanks to you guys for suffering it. If you have any suggestions of opinions of areas please contact me or leave them here.
Thanks

http://steamcommunity.com/id/howser/
jope
Noavatar
Team Awesome
Posts
59
Location
Norway
Joined
7 April 2013
10 February 2014 - 23:46 CET
#12
Thank you for being so active with your involvement.
We only played a short marine round yesterday on your most recent changes.

Couple things:

There is problems sometimes for dropping med packs. I was in uranus near the vents and the meds would just drop in the vent. This also happened somewhere else but I can't remember.

One opinion I have is, some people mentioned the vents were too hard to see and such, however now I notice some vents are super super bright, when running up to anti chamber and just after reception. They are yellow and then also inside it looks like a light is on. I think the vents are better when they are like the couple of ones which are on the right side or near upload. just covered in red but you can still see if a skulk is inside it.

Also one of our players got stuck when he jumped down near the pillar in upload. it was the same spot i hid as a gorge in our crazy 75 minute map. I think you said you made a change there(vent above it)
The marine round map was streamed on http://twitch.tv/tagwolftv if you want to review our marine rd vs wonga. sadly it wasn't another 75 min match
cheers
blind
Noavatar
onFire
Posts
578
Location
Mannheim, Germany
Joined
3 November 2009
16 February 2014 - 01:44 CET
#13
Generally put, I love the map, think it has most potential out of the custom maps. Especially like the *clean* design, so sick and tired of all the ns2_more_crates_and_shit_all_around maps.
Howser
Noavatar
Modder
ns2_fracture
Posts
10
Location
Earth
Joined
19 September 2013
16 February 2014 - 20:06 CET
#14
Thanks Blind. Its a punishing map for pub games as you have to be an aggressive marine side with the three RT's with an alien bias.
The latest build is built around the Idea of having 'lanes' much like a MOBA map. One thing I have noticed as marines is choosing 2 lanes and pushing up into aliens territory is a much better approach than trying to maintain the marine side (all three RTs) of the map.
I had a break this week but next week I'll crack on with improving the right side of the map, specifically prep and the view.
So if any of you guys play it please post your thoughts and outcomes of the games... Crates are so 2010, Pillars are the new crates!
Howser
Noavatar
Modder
ns2_fracture
Posts
10
Location
Earth
Joined
19 September 2013
25 February 2014 - 16:38 CET
#15
New update today. A few minor fixes but one quite significant change that I would really like some feedback from comp players on ASAP.
The problem I noticed is aliens were having too much of an easy time sitting back and playing the res waiting game while marines often struggled to establish a forward base out side of the middle line (Ceremony, The park and Cold storage). Another issue was that the View was extremely hard for marines to harass if aliens had setup in cold storage. So the best solution i came up with is to rework 'the bigfanthing' with a room that not only gave marines a staging ground on the alien side of the map but much easier access for assaulting arrivals and the view RT locations. The choke points leading to this new area (marked in green)are purposely set-forward to encourage aliens to take the fight for territory to the marines and be more risky with their forward base building.

http://i.imgur.com/fSGi6P8.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/1Oqt4S7.jpg

Well that's the thought process behind the changes. It's a fairly risky change so I'd like to hear about how it actually plays in a competitive game.

The other changes are:
*Downsized the central space in marine start to make it easier for aliens to assault.
*Fixed a Stuck spot in antechamber (thanks Yaluzan).
*Made vent in upload accessible by marines so aliens cannot safely sit and wait for marines to pass before harassing the RT.


Yaluzan
3786
Admin Abuse
Posts
174
Location
Netherlands
Joined
18 November 2012
25 July 2015 - 18:23 CEST
#16
Bumped for new CMC
6am6p
Noavatar
Posts
1
Location
Russian Federation
Joined
15 January 2014
26 July 2015 - 17:57 CEST
#17
Area without powernode
http://www.twitch.tv/ns2rus/v/8538955?t=31m34s
CRaZyCAT
4159
Horror Show
Admins
Ref Admin
Posts
105
Location
Omsk (Siberia), Russian Federation
Joined
3 December 2012
26 July 2015 - 22:00 CEST
#18
6am6p says
Area without powernode
http://www.twitch.tv/ns2rus/v/8538955?t=31m34s


https://youtu.be/WMVHjLP-3N4?t=18m19s
18:59 and 19:23

PGs not powered
Battle.net: CRaZyCAT #222106
New Reply